Pakistan Customs has rejected media reports alleging import fraud and under-invoicing of goods from China, saying that differences in mirror trade data cannot be treated as conclusive proof on their own. The department said such gaps need proper reconciliation and verification, and that the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has taken corrective steps to improve data reporting.
Background
Mirror trade data means comparing what one country reports as exports to another with what the other country reports as imports from it. Large gaps between the two figures are sometimes pointed to as a sign that goods are being declared at lower values than their real price.
The issue has drawn attention because several local industries have long raised concerns about undervalued imports. Pakistan Customs responded to the latest media reports in a statement issued on Tuesday.
Details
According to the statement, discrepancies in the bilateral trade data that Pakistan and China report to the International Trade Centre (ITC) were examined extensively. Customs said these comparisons have inherent limitations because institutions and countries use different methods to retrieve, compile and report data.
The department said a reported discrepancy of 32 percent in 2023 was reduced to just 0.54 percent after reconciliation. It added that the FBR has also taken corrective measures to improve data reporting, which have been in place since July 2026.
Customs also highlighted the role of the Directorate General of Customs Valuation, which it says gives priority to concerns of local manufacturers. These include the textile, steel, chemicals, tyres, stationery, dyes, plastics, glass, light engineering goods and automotive vendor industries. The department described the issuance and revision of valuation rulings as an ongoing process, aimed at keeping customs values dynamic, realistic and sustainable.
The directorate in Karachi has fixed customs values and issued valuation rulings under Section 25A of the Customs Act, 1969, covering various yarns and fabrics. Customs says these were prepared in consultation with industry associations and stakeholders, and are based on internationally recognised price publications, current global market trends and other parameters. The major ruling on polyester filament yarn has been revised to match international market trends.
New valuation exercises are also underway for existing rulings and for additional textile products, including mink yarn, raw white core spun blended yarn, cotton yarn and billiard cloth. Customs said these will be completed within the specified timeframe.
Quotes
Pakistan Customs said in its statement that mirror trade data discrepancies, on their own, cannot be treated as conclusive evidence of under-invoicing and require proper reconciliation and verification. The department did not name the media reports it was responding to, and the specific allegations in those reports were not detailed in its statement.
Impact
The statement is important for importers, local manufacturers and revenue authorities alike. If under-invoicing is widespread, it can reduce government revenue and put domestic producers at a price disadvantage, which is why industry groups often press for stricter valuation. On the other hand, Customs argues that raw data gaps can overstate the problem unless they are carefully reconciled.
The department’s emphasis on valuation rulings also signals that it wants to be seen as responsive to industry concerns, especially in textiles, where yarn and fabric prices directly affect local mills. How industry groups react to the revised rulings and the new reconciliation figure will show whether the explanation is accepted.
Conclusion
Customs has said that the new valuation exercises will be completed within the specified timeframe. Industry stakeholders and the media are likely to watch whether the revised rulings and improved data reporting from July 2026 lead to more consistent customs values, and whether the reconciliation process is explained in more detail.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Pakistan Customs reject the under-invoicing claims?
Pakistan Customs said that discrepancies in mirror trade data cannot, on their own, be treated as conclusive evidence of under-invoicing. It explained that such comparisons involve China’s reported exports to Pakistan and Pakistan’s reported imports from China, and that differences in data retrieval, compilation and reporting practices create inherent limitations. According to the department, a reported discrepancy of 32 percent in 2023 was reduced to 0.54 percent after reconciliation.
What steps have the FBR and Customs taken?
The FBR has taken corrective measures to improve data reporting, which have been in place since July 2026. The Directorate General of Customs Valuation has also issued valuation rulings under Section 25A of the Customs Act, 1969, covering various yarns and fabrics, in consultation with industry associations. The major ruling on polyester filament yarn has been revised in line with international market trends, and fresh valuation exercises are underway for mink yarn, raw white core spun blended yarn, cotton yarn and billiard cloth.
Which industries does Customs say it is prioritising?
Customs said the valuation directorate gives priority to the concerns of local manufacturing industries, including textiles, steel, chemicals, tyres, stationery, dyes, plastics, glass, light engineering goods and automotive vendors. It described the issuance and revision of valuation rulings as an ongoing process, with the aim of ensuring dynamic, realistic and sustainable customs values, though the statement did not give details of which specific complaints it was addressing.

Leave a comment