Madhubala, the 22-year-old elephant at Karachi’s Safari Park, is now free of tuberculosis, but the disease has left her weak and in need of several more weeks of intensive care. Dr Amir Khalil of Four Paws says her low immunity, weight loss and weak hind legs remain serious concerns.
Background
Madhubala and her sister Malika are Pakistan’s last two captive African elephants. Both were brought to Karachi from Tanzania in 2010 along with two other elephants, Noor Jehan and Sonia, in an arrangement that drew criticism.
The group’s story has been marked by loss. Noor Jehan died at Karachi Zoo in April 2023, and Sonia died at Safari Park in December 2024. Madhubala was moved from the zoo to Safari Park in November 2024 under Four Paws supervision, and both she and Malika later tested positive for tuberculosis and were treated for about a year and a half. The public reaction to the deaths led the Karachi Metropolitan Corporation to form an 18-member body to oversee the elephants’ care.
Details
Speaking to The Express Tribune at Safari Park, Khalil said Madhubala is now free of the disease, but its lingering effects are the main problem. Her immune system is weak, she has lost weight, and her physical condition has declined. Her hind legs are especially weak, and swelling in her limbs and cracks in her toenails have affected how she moves.
Madhubala has been unwell for several weeks. A bacterial infection was suspected at first, but Khalil said there is no longer any evidence of one. According to Daily Pakistan, she collapsed on September 14 and had to be lifted with the help of a crane. Khalil warned that she may need a crane again to get back on her feet if she falls.
Her treatment plan goes beyond medication. She will receive multivitamins, minerals and dietary supplements, with particular attention to liver health. Daily water-based massages and physiotherapy are planned to improve blood circulation in her leg muscles, and swimming will help her move her legs while slowly rebuilding strength. Arab News reported that part of the Safari Park pool will be deepened by about one metre so she can exercise in water without carrying her full weight.
Treating an elephant brings special challenges, Khalil said, including how difficult it is to give injections. Pakistani and foreign specialists are working together, and international experts have been guiding the team remotely over the past several weeks.
Quotes
On her weight, Khalil told reporters, “She lost a lot of weight, over 200 kilograms.” He said there are encouraging signs of improvement, but that it is too early to make definite predictions, and that the priority for now is to stabilise her condition and provide intensive care. He also noted that Malika has been looking after her sister and playing an important role in her care.
Impact
Madhubala’s case has drawn public attention because she is one of only two elephants left in the country, and because earlier elephant deaths in Karachi triggered public anger. Her recovery is being watched as a test of whether the city’s improved care arrangements can protect the surviving animals.
The case also shows that beating a disease is not always the end of treatment. Long and heavy medication, followed by weakness and muscle loss, can require months of nutrition, physiotherapy and specialised rehabilitation, particularly for a large animal that cannot easily be moved or handled.
Conclusion
The veterinary team expects Madhubala to need several more weeks of intensive treatment. Visitors and animal lovers will be waiting for updates on whether she can regain strength in her hind legs and stand and walk on her own without assistance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Madhubala the elephant free of tuberculosis?
Yes. Dr Amir Khalil of Four Paws told The Express Tribune that the 22-year-old elephant is now free of the disease. Arab News reported that she tested negative at her last examination in May, after earlier treatment that lasted about a year and a half. Even so, the effects of the illness and its long treatment have left her weak, and she still needs several weeks of intensive care.
What health problems does Madhubala still have?
Madhubala has a weakened immune system, has lost more than 200 kilograms in weight, and has weak hind legs. She also has swelling in her limbs and cracks in her toenails, which affect how she walks. A bacterial infection was suspected earlier, but Khalil said there is now no evidence of one. Because of her weakness, she may need a crane to help her stand again if she falls, as happened on September 14.
How is Madhubala being treated?
Her treatment combines nutrition and rehabilitation instead of relying only on medicine. She will receive multivitamins, minerals and supplements, with special attention to liver health, along with daily water-based massages and physiotherapy to improve circulation in her legs. Swimming will help her exercise her legs while rebuilding muscle, and part of the Safari Park pool is being deepened for this purpose. Pakistani and foreign specialists are working together, with international experts advising remotely, and her sister Malika is also helping care for her.

Leave a comment